Cisco Systems (NASDAQ: CSCO) may have abandoned the InfiniBand market in favor of Fibre Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) and 10GbE, but the rest of the InfiniBand market appears to be carrying on just fine without the networking giant, according to industry analysts and other vendors.
"Although InfiniBand remains a small industry compared to the Ethernet juggernaut, it continues to grow aggressively, and this year it is growing beyond projections," said Jeff Boles, senior analyst and director of validation services at the Taneja Group.
When Performance Matters
In high performance computing (HPC) environments, for example, InfiniBand (IB) is still the dominant protocol, according to a March 2009 Tabor Research report titled "InfiniBand: Increases in Speed, Usage, Competition." According to the report, 60 percent of HPC organizations surveyed said they used InfiniBand as a system interconnect. And those HPC organizations that were considering a converged fabric strategy said they were more likely to consolidate on InfiniBand than on Ethernet.http://o1.qnsr.com/log/p.gif?;n=203;c=204655439;s=10655;x=7936;f=201806121855330;u=j;z=TIMESTAMP;a=20400368;e=i
HPC isn't the only area where InfiniBand continues to make inroads. Oracle (NASDAQ: ORCL) is utilizing InfiniBand in the HP Oracle Database Machine, Exadata. "And we're seeing other database vendors following in Oracle's steps and creating their own interfaces, which will allow them to connect directly to InfiniBand," said Gilad Shainer, director of technical marketing at IB chipmaker Mellanox (NASDAQ: MLNX).
InfiniBand is also an attractive option for organizations with high-throughput processing needs that are looking for a localized fabric. The protocol is also gaining traction in the virtualization and cloud computing arenas, which require high bandwidth and low latency, as well as with organizations looking to reduce their power consumption and real estate without giving up performance.
Because InfiniBand can be used as a unified fabric, "you can run your storage, you can run your network, you can run your database, and you can run your management all on the same wire," explained Shainer. "And once you do that you can eliminate unnecessary components and unnecessary networks in your infrastructure. So if you take out a dedicated network from management, and you take out a dedicated network from storage, you have less components in your data center, less cabling, less switches, less NICs, and of course reduced consumption of power and cooling."
Indeed, compared to Gigabit Ethernet, even 10 Gigabit Ethernet, 20 GB/s and 40GB/s InfiniBand provides much greater speed and system efficiency and a lower total cost of ownership. Not that Ethernet speeds won't get faster, however.
"When you're looking at a unified solution, it is enormously cheaper to do InfiniBand in a localized cloud pool [for example] than it is to try to provision traditional storage and traditional networking connectivity in the same set of servers," said Boles. Similarly, "when compared to a single 40Gb/s QDR InfiniBand fabric, traditional fabrics can more than double what it costs to operate and manage I/O in virtual server infrastructures."
However, as the cost of 10GbE continues to decline, enterprises that have already made a significant investment in Ethernet may be less inclined to adopt InfiniBand. That's why some InfiniBand vendors are hedging their bets.
Hedging Bets with 10 Gigabit Ethernet
In June, Voltaire (NASDAQ: VOLT) announced that it plans to release the Voltaire Vantage 8500 10 Gigabit Ethernet switch, which it claims is the largest non-blocking Ethernet data center switch with 288 wire speed and 10 Gigabit Ethernet ports in a 15U high chassis, intended for enterprise data centers and cloud computing environments. And competitor QLogic (NASDAQ: QLGC), fresh off its NetXen acquisition, announced the introduction of its new line of 3100 Series Intelligent Ethernet Adapters, offering fast 10GbE connectivity for bandwidth-intensive applications such as virtualization, database clustering, IP content delivery and grid computing.
Despite these moves, however, both companies are continuing to sell and support and come out with new InfiniBand adapters and switches, at least for now, as is Mellanox, although other vendors, most notably Cisco, no longer are.
Indeed, in a recent e-mail, Cisco spokesperson Lee Davis wrote that while Cisco felt InfiniBand "is an excellent protocol, we believe the future lies with the new Data Center Ethernet, which combines the ease of management and high performance Ethernet with the reliability of Fibre Channel (no packet loss)."
Cisco made a splash four years ago when it paid $250 million to enter the IB market through the acquisition of Topspin Communications.
Will IB Play Nicely with Ethernet?
When asked about the future of InfiniBand, Mellanox's Shainer was optimistic. "The number of InfiniBand customers has been increasing. The number of market segments [where InfiniBand is being adopted] is increasing. Volume has been increasing. And we're seeing increased demand from the market for higher performance and higher networking capabilities," which is no doubt why Mellanox experienced a significant increase in sales, mainly of its 40GB/s InfiniBand adapters and switches, in the first half of the year, with demand showing no sign of slowing.
"InfiniBand was thought to be a networking solution for the high-performance computing segment only, but that's really not true," explained Shainer. "InfiniBand enables you to run any kind of application, any kind of transport, and can be used for a database, for HPC, for storage, for management. And InfiniBand enables you to do the same kind of things that you were doing with an Ethernet infrastructure ... but significantly increases your system's efficiency and utilization. And InfiniBand is not a niche technology. It's fully supported by the Linux vendors, the Linux community, by Microsoft, and by many others. It's perfect for virtualization, for cloud computing, for any kind of usage."
When asked to look in his crystal ball and see what the future holds for InfiniBand and whether FCoE and 10GbE pose a significant threat Boles said he didn't see any significant changes in the marketplace in the next three to six months and felt both protocols would be viable in the short and medium term.
As for the long run, "I think InfiniBand is going to find tremendous opportunity to solve some sticky issues in the data center, especially when it comes to pockets of cloud computing that have very high I/O demands," Boles said. "And you'll find InfiniBand where there's a bunch of localized servers and storage with high-performance demands, as well as in traditional enterprises and businesses that don't consider themselves HPC experts but have high-performance I/O workloads, which are rapidly exceeding even converged Ethernet, 10GbE."
However, he said that ultimately, "I think we may see some convergence," which he saw as a good thing, "with each technology bringing its best assets to the table."
Jennifer Lonoff Schiff is a regular contributor to Enterprise Storage Forum and writes about technology.
Follow Enterprise Storage Forum on Twitter